Friday, March 25, 2011

Loopholes in Norway’s support for Low Carbon Development Strategy to Guyana exposed

The Norwegian Minister of the Environment & International Development - Erik Solheim, will be visiting Guyana (a country with one of the largest unspoiled rainforests in South America, some parts of which are almost inaccessible by humans) in the last week of March 2011 amidst complaints about poor performance of the Norwegian supported five-year Low Carbon Development Strategy worth $US250M which was agreed in 2009. The funds have been released in agreed tranches.
But a year ago, Solheim congratulated Guyana’s President Bharrat Jagdeo when he was awarded the United Nations’ 2010 Champion of the Earth. Solheim described Jagdeo’s promotion of low carbon development as “an example for others to follow.”

In fact the ACP / EU Courier magazine (January / February 2011) carries a special report on Guyana: Trailblazing a low carbon development: Bold or risky? and an interview with President Bharrat Jagdeo himself, on ‘developing Guyana with a low carbon footprint’. According to the President, Guyana’s Low Carbon Development strategy is designed in such a way that more donors can join in at any point

But according to members of civil society and two Members of Parliament, there are glaring loopholes that need to be sorted out before the worthwhile programme can continue in Guyana. In this regard, they have written a letter which suggests that there are at least eight reasons why Solheim should perhaps revise his opinion of President Jagdeo and take a more critical look at Norway’s support for his Low Carbon Development Strategy. The letter recommends that Norway should not release any funds to Guyana on the grounds that Guyana has “substantially failed to implement the MoU, either in spirit or in practice.”

Read the full Civil Society letter to the Norwegian Minister of the Environment & International Development - Erik Solheim, ahead of his visit to Guyana

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Rio+20: Urgent Appeal to Change the Mindset

Environmentalists, economists, feminists and social activists from all over the world, after many years of criticizing governments are now calling for States to be strengthened as the only way to save the planet, threatened by a whole series of crises in climate, water, food and finances. On Monday, March 7th, sixteen members of the self-appointed Reflection Group on global development perspectives formulated a call to “change the mindset" about environmental and economic problems.

This call is aimed primarily at the negotiators who are preparing the United Nations Summit for Sustainable Development, which will be held in Rio de Janeiro in 2012, twenty years after the “Earth Summit”, where the concept of sustainable development was endorsed and the foundations were laid for conventions on climate change, desertification and deforestation. The changed mindset they are now demanding begins with “restoring public rights over corporate privileges”.

The statement asserts that “unbridled market forces have favoured the strong, thereby widening the economic divide. This requires the State to redress the imbalance, eliminate discrimination, and ensure sustainable livelihoods, decent work and social inclusion. Intergenerational justice requires restraint and responsibility of the present generation. It is urgent to establish more equitable per capita rights towards the global commons and to the emission of greenhouse gases, taking fully into account historical responsibility”. The more developed countries have not accepted these last two principles, and this is what has blocked progress in negotiations about climate change.

The signatories do not adhere to Malthusian ideas about the exhaustion of resources and maintain instead that "knowledge-intensive solutions including technologies are available to restore natural systems, and dramatically reduce pressures on climate and the environment while improving human well-being”. They argue that a “green economy” is possible, but insist that this must be integrated into “a holistic concept of sustainability”. They conclude that what we need “a change of lifestyles”.

To achieve this, “The Rio 2012 Summit must re-affirm the State as the indispensable actor setting the legal frame, enforcing standards of equity and human rights, and fostering long-term ecological thinking, based on democratic legitimacy”.

View the Urgent Appeal to Change the Mindset from here

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Green economy – learning from the Caribbean

Blogger - Steve shares his thoughts from a Caribbean dialogue on green economy, run by the University of the West Indies and Caribbean Natural Resources Institute. An eclectic mix of government ministers, academics, community leaders and business associations rightly kept the few international observers in check – part of the problem being that small countries suffer often overwhelming outside economic, cultural and environmental influence.

From this Dialogue, the lesson was that Caribbean green economies are about actively building resilience, including

- Regional integration, e.g. a Caribbean single market enabling free movement of labour and capital, and trade agreements built on environmental and labour standards and that do not undermine local production for local consumption

- Disaster preparedness and business continuity planning – including at the micro-enterprise level

- Fixing the housing industry to shift to low-energy and resource efficiency, and resilient buildings

- Taking industries higher up the value chain through better use of biodiversity and culture

- Realising real value from links with Caribbean diaspora all over the world e.g. through food market chains

- Recognising good natural resource management by local communities and assuring the rights and support to sustain livelihoods

In addition Steve Bass raises the questions on the concept of green economy:

- Is its elevation to UN negotiating table also good news? Many developing countries are worried that it appears to be yet another Northern consensus which will lead to overly high production standards and green protectionism.

- Why can’t green economy also mean ‘high-carbon’ landscapes, sustaining livelihoods and industries based on wise use of biodiversity and ecosystems?

- Can it foster the resource efficiency and innovation inherent in the informal sector, and not just tinker with big banks and corporations?

Steve argues that we cannot rely on the same paradigm – economic growth at all costs, stealing from the future – to solve the very problems that this paradigm creates: poverty, inequality, and environmental degradation.

He makes a strong observation that a serious reflection on UNEP’s Green Economy Report cannot repeat the common mistake of international bureaucracies, i.e. jumping straight to countries preparing ‘national plans’ based on a global report. This tends to both impose external ideas and miss the real (local) drivers of change. Instead, every country needs the space to reflect on what green economy means (you don’t get very far until you explore it for a particular economy), what is already in place that can be ‘scaled up’, and what constraints are in the way.

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Inclusive and Sustainable Development: For Whom?

The focus of the development policy discourse now seems firmly fixed on “inclusiveness”; as both process and outcome. This is clear from the focus of the UN Secretary General’s Agenda for 2011, the discussions at Davos in January 2011 and the theme of the 2011 UNDP Human Development Report: Sustainability and Equity.

As the world's attention turns towards the roll-out of the Green Climate Fund and the discussions at Rio+20, Leisa Perch of the International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth asks what lessons we can take forward in light of the triple challenge:

- mitigating the worst impacts of environmental change, in whatever form it takes, including climate change.

- Safeguarding the social and economic progress achieved, including the sharing of the risks and benefits of development actions, avoiding both “free riding” and “overburdening of the poor”.

- Ensuring the compatibility of development actions at various levels.

Leisa then argues that for improved development outcomes, particularly for the poor
and vulnerable, intensified efforts at the level of scope and scale will be needed. She further notes that as discussions escalate around the shape and scope of the“green economy” and about institutional frameworks for securing sustainable development, the first order of business should be to define what “green” means; particularly in a socially sustainable context. Moreover, an honest discussion on equity in the context of risk-sharing, burden-sharing and benefit-sharing is paramount.

Read the full one pager from the International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth - Inclusive and Sustainable Development: For Whom?

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

UN support for national preparations for the UN Conference for Sustainable Development (UNCSD – Rio+20) welcome

Many developing countries have capacity and resource constraints which makes it difficult for them to provide for robust national level preparations for International negotiations like the Rio20 Conference. These constraints will hinder proper review and assessment of implementation, identification of gaps and challenges that should result in national reports as part of the preparatory process.

In addition, one of the Rio20 themes - 'green economy' remains unclear to various stakeholders including Civil society. But as noted by the UN, targeted support to developing countries to clarify themes and to increase their engagement with the developed and middle income countries to prepare for Rio20, would boost their input and the likelihood of implementation of the outcomes:

' The theme of green economy since its inception has attracted a number of views in relation to its applicability to the development agenda. Not least, there is no unified view of what represents a green economy. While this project proposal is not aiming to define the concept further, it does propose to support a demand driven process that assists countries define their individual contexts for more sustainable development approaches. These may encompass aspects of green economy to a lesser or greater extent. In addition to green economy issues the themes of the conference will need to be informed by the views of member states on how the outcomes from the original Earth Summit in 1992 has added to their development agendas and what needs strengthening for the economic, social and environmental pillars to be fully integrated'

Read the full Concept Note for Supporting National Preparations for The United Nations Conference for Sustainable Development, UNCSD Rio+20, 2012 Prepared by DESA and UNDP

Saturday, January 29, 2011

Spark innovation. Lead by action: UN Secretary General to the World Economic Forum (Davos)

The UN Secretary General has called on for a speedy return to sustainable development at the World Economic Forum - a meeting of the 'mighty and the powerful'. Calling sustainable development the growth agenda for the 21st century, Mr. Ban recited a litany of development errors based on a false belief in the infinite abundance of natural resources that fueled the economy in the last century.

He told the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, in a session devoted to redefining sustainable development that, “We are running out of time. Time to tackle climate change. Time to ensure sustainable, climate-resilient green growth. Time to generate a clean energy revolution.”

He emphasized that to secure sustainable development, we have to be prepared to make major changes – in our lifestyles, our economic models, our social organization, and our political life. We have to connect the dots between climate change and what I might call here, WEF – water, energy and food.” WEF is also the acronym for the Davos World Economic Forum.

“We need you to step up. Spark innovation. Lead by action. Invest in energy efficiency and renewable energy for those who need them most – your future customers. Expand clean energy access in developing countries – your markets of tomorrow.”

More

Thursday, January 27, 2011

Obama 's 'clean energy economy': who ought to benefit?

In this year's State of the Union address, delivered by US President Barack Obama, the core message was that The US will continue to pursue a green growth strategy, aimed at creating jobs and exports through clean tech innovation in areas like solar,biofuels, ”clean coal”, nuclear and high speed rail.

Despite tough opposition from the Republican side on energy and climate change related issues, the US President reiterated his wows create the ”clean energy economy” he campaigned for in 2008. More

According to Larry West, the Environmentalists will appreciate Obama's commitment to create a clean-energy economy and his pledge to enforce regulations that will ensure clean air and water, food safety and public health. On the other hand, they are sure to be disappointed by his insistence on continuing to include clean coal and nuclear power as part of America's clean-energy portfolio(nuclear power part of genuinely clean energy?)--as he did in his first State of the Union address in 2010.

From a Southern perspective, I think that more 'green spinoffs' from US innovation that Obama refers to in his speech needs to target the global South:

"...What we can do - what America does better than anyone - is spark the creativity and imagination of our people. We are the nation that put cars in driveways and computers in offices; the nation of Edison and the Wright brothers; of Google and Facebook. In America, innovation doesn't just change our lives. It's how we make a living..."

Since the market for the innovation has high opportunities in the(global) South, the US should provide deliberate response to global basic needs in affordable renewable energy, and technology transfer.

This will make the less fortunate 'clients' (people) the world over (based on the Millennium Development Goals bench marks and progress to date), a lot happier than they are today (moral and ethical obligations) - and hence increase their disposable incomes which is in the best interest of the US. For example in improved public health, sustainable agriculture and food security.